In the past few days, particularly since the Federal High Court in Abuja remanded the journalist Daniel Ojukwu in the Kuje Correctional Centre pending the hearing of his bail application, I have read several interventions on his behalf. I have also been contacted by a representative of the Committee to Protect Journalists, who raised a number of concerns about the remand. I respect the passion behind these interventions. Nobody who values a free society should be indifferent when a journalist is in custody. But passion is not a substitute for fairness, and it is precisely fairness that has been missing from much of what I have read.

Most of the interventions failed the most basic test of journalism: they did not give the other side a hearing. Audi alteram partem (hear the other side) is not only a principle of natural justice that lawyers recite in court; it is the first rule of every newsroom worth the name. Yet almost every piece I have seen was written as though there was only one party to this matter. The stories were slanted entirely in favour of the defendant, and their central claim was simple: a journalist exposed corruption, and for that he was thrown into jail. If the matter were that simple, it would never have reached where it is today. It deserves a more careful telling. Let us start with the facts as they stand. It was neither the complainant nor the police that remanded Mr. Ojukwu. It was a court of law, the very institution our Constitution empowers to deal with such matters.
The journalist was arraigned on a 12-count charge of alleged cyberstalking and criminal defamation. He pleaded not guilty, as is his right, and the court adjourned the hearing of his bail application to December 1, ordering that he be kept in custody in the meantime. That is all that has happened. No judgment has been delivered. No one has been convicted. No court has said that Mr. Ojukwu is guilty of anything. What took place was an arraignment, the preliminary stage at which a defendant takes his plea and sets about applying for and perfecting his bail. It is the beginning of a trial, not its end. I say this not to diminish the hardship of detention.
Every day a citizen spends in custody is a serious matter, and I would expect the bail application to be heard and determined promptly and on its merits. But it is misleading to describe a routine procedural stage as though it were a final verdict handed down to punish a man for his reporting. Consider the position of the complainant. She has been publicly accused of serious wrongdoing. What is she expected to do? She cannot take the law into her own hands. The civilised option open to her, and to every citizen in her position, is to lodge a complaint with the appropriate law enforcement agency and ask that it be investigated. That is exactly what the law expects of a citizen who believes she has been wronged. It is also worth remembering that the police are not obliged to act on every complaint.
They are under no compulsion to investigate a petition in the first place, and they are under no obligation to charge anyone to court where their investigation does not disclose a prima facie case. When the police decide to arraign a suspect, therefore, they are not condemning him. They are placing the matter before a neutral arbiter and giving the defendant a platform to justify what he did. If he is sure of his facts, the courtroom is where he proves them. The presumption of innocence that rightly protects Mr Ojukwu also cuts the other way. The allegations he published against the complainant are, until established, allegations. She too is entitled to be presumed innocent of them, and she too is entitled to her day in court. A society that extends the benefit of the doubt only to the side it sympathises with has abandoned the idea of justice altogether.
Other News
The tone of many of the interventions suggests that journalists are above the law simply because they are journalists, and that they are free to operate with impunity. I do not believe that is what their authors intend, but it is the message their writing sends. How do we justify recklessness in destroying the reputation of another citizen? Reputation is not a small thing. For many people it is the sum of a lifetime’s work, and once it is damaged it is very hard to repair. The prosecution in this case is under the Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act, whose Section 24, as amended in 2024, criminalises cyberstalking. One may argue, as many have, that the law should be further reformed, and that argument belongs in the National Assembly. But for as long as the law remains in force, we are all under an obligation to obey it.
Several lawyers are currently being prosecuted in court under the same provision, as are many other citizens from every walk of life. Journalists cannot claim a special exemption that the rest of society does not enjoy. A person who believes he has been defamed or harassed online is at liberty to pursue civil remedies, criminal remedies, or both. That choice belongs to the victim, and the law permits it. Under the rule of law, nobody is above the law, whatever his profession. I am sure that the authors of those interventions would not say that a journalist may harass or defame anyone without consequence. If that is so, then the honest position is to let the court do its work and to judge the case on the evidence, not on the profession of the accused.
Around the world, lives have been shattered and reputations destroyed by the recklessness of a few journalists. Those few are doing great damage to the image of the many credible, hard-working and courageous men and women who make up the overwhelming majority of the profession. Defending every journalist reflexively, regardless of the facts, does those good journalists no favours. It erodes the public trust on which their work depends. Let no one mistake my position for hostility to the press. I have, over the years, and even now, defended journalists charged under this same Act.
Where there was no justification for the charge, the courts set them free. I am probably the first lawyer in this country to defend a journalist under the Cybercrimes Act, a fact Seun Oloketuyi can confirm. When the 9th National Assembly attempted to regulate social media, I was at the forefront of the resistance against that attempt to gag the press and the public. I believe completely in press freedom. But freedom without responsibility soon becomes licence, and licence is the enemy of an orderly society. The Constitution guarantees freedom of expression, but it also protects the dignity of every citizen. Both rights must live side by side.
For society to function, each of us must respect the rights of others, and the pen confers no exemption from that duty. This brings me to the heart of the matter. Much of the friction we are now witnessing between the press and the criminal justice system arises because the profession has not built strong enough mechanisms to police itself. When a citizen believes a newspaper or an online platform has wronged him, where does he go? Too often, the honest answer is nowhere, except the police station or the courtroom. If I may make a suggestion, the Nigerian Union of Journalists needs to urgently strengthen its internal regulation.
Specifically, it should establish an independent, credible window through which innocent citizens who are victims of irresponsible journalism can lodge complaints and obtain a remedy. Such a body should be able to investigate complaints quickly, compel corrections and retractions, require apologies and rights of reply to be published with due prominence, and sanction members who repeatedly breach the profession’s code of ethics, including by suspending their membership.
This is not a new idea. Mature democracies have long relied on press councils and ombudsmen, set up and funded largely by the media industry itself, to resolve complaints without resort to the police. Self-regulation of this kind protects press freedom precisely because it gives the state less reason, and less excuse, to intervene. I speak from experience. I have myself been a victim of reckless journalism, and I know first-hand the damage it does to one’s reputation and career. On such occasions, a quick and credible correction would have been worth far more to me than any lawsuit. Many complainants would gladly choose that route if it existed and if it worked.
Once such a unit is established and made effective, it will reduce the number of complaints that end up at police stations. Fewer journalists will find themselves in handcuffs, fewer citizens will feel that the criminal law is their only refuge, and the profession will win back public confidence that it badly needs. The NUJ would then be speaking from a position of moral strength when it defends a member who has done nothing wrong. The case of Daniel Ojukwu is now before the court, and that is where it should be resolved, on the evidence and according to law. Those who wish to support him are entitled to do so, but they owe the public the same balance and fairness that good journalism demands. Shouting down one side of a story is not advocacy for press freedom; it is a betrayal of the very standard that makes the press worth defending. Press freedom and accountability are not enemies. They are two sides of the same coin. A press that holds the powerful to account must itself be willing to be held to account. The Nigerian Union of Journalists has an opportunity to show leadership by building the structures that make that possible. It should seize it now, before another journalist ends up in a cell and another citizen ends up with a ruined name, when a simple, fair and independent complaints process might have spared them both.

Follow Us on Google
