Security guard to die by hanging for killing man in Enugu

Court

From Jude Chinedu, Enugu

The High Court in Enugu State has sentenced a security guard, Shuaibu Mohammed, to death by hanging for killing a man, Njoku Nwabueze, during a dispute at the Soil Plaza, Emene, Enugu.

Justice Kenneth Okpe, who delivered the judgment yesterday, found Mohammed guilty of murder, holding that the prosecution had proved the charge against him beyond reasonable doubt. The defendant was represented by C. C. Azubuike, while C. N. Avah, a Director in the Enugu State Ministry of Justice, prosecuted the case.

Mohammed was accused of stabbing Nwabueze with a dagger on October 1, 2021, following a disagreement at the plaza, where he worked as a security guard. The court held that the defendant’s confessional statements, coupled with other evidence presented by the prosecution, established that he committed the crime.

In his judgment, Justice Okpe said the defendant had admitted stabbing the deceased at the back of the left side of his chest during a quarrel over an alleged theft. The judge noted that although the defendant denied the allegation while testifying in court, he did not retract or address the two confessional statements he made to the police in his written deposition.

Justice Okpe observed that the statements made before two different police officers at different locations and on separate occasions were consistent in their material details.

He said: “The two confessional statements were made before two police officers, the PW1 and PW2, at different locations and on different days. I have, again, thoroughly read the two confessional statements and they are saying basically and essentially the same thing.”

The judge further held that the prosecution was not required to produce a witness to secure a conviction, explaining that a murder charge could be established through a confessional statement, circumstantial evidence, or direct evidence. He said the defendant’s decision to abandon his duty post and flee to Eke Obinagu after the incident also formed part of the circumstantial evidence against him.

“If the Defendant did not kill the deceased and did not even fight with him, why did he go into hiding? What was he running away from, particularly as, according to him, he was not the only Hausa security man at the Plaza?” the judge queried.

Justice Okpe also dismissed the defence argument that the confessional statements were inadmissible because they were not video-recorded and were not made in the presence of the defendant’s lawyer, as provided under Section 17 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Enugu State, 2017.

He held that there was no evidence that the defendant was tortured, threatened, or subjected to any form of oppression before making the statements. The judge also rejected the defence of provocation and self-defence, which he considered in the circumstances of the case.

On provocation, he held that even if the deceased had attacked the defendant, stabbing him with a dagger was disproportionate to the alleged provocation.

Dismissing the claim of self-defence, the judge noted that the deceased was stabbed at the back, indicating that he was no longer facing the defendant when the fatal attack occurred.

“The evidence showed that the deceased was no longer attacking the Defendant when the Defendant stabbed him and, therefore, the defence of self-defence will also not avail the Defendant,” he ruled.

The court consequently held that the prosecution had established all three ingredients of murder: the death of the deceased, that it resulted from the defendant’s unlawful act and that the act was intentional, with knowledge that death or grievous bodily harm was its probable consequence.

During allocutus, counsel to the defendant pleaded for mercy, while the prosecution confirmed that Mohammed had no previous record of conviction. However, Justice Okpe said the court had no discretion to impose a lesser punishment because Section 274(1) of the Criminal Code Law of Enugu State prescribes death for murder. He, subsequently, sentenced Mohammed to death by hanging.

“May God have mercy on his soul,” the judge added.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.

Breaking news & top stories

Follow The Sun Newspaper

Get live updates & exclusive stories delivered straight to your phone.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.