Inherited mind and dreams beyond control: Religion, karma, scientology and unanswered questions of human consciousness (III)

Logo New2

As this series progresses, we now turn to some of the more intriguing questions surrounding human consciousness and the nature of dreams. Can everything we experience while sleeping be explained by the activities of the brain, or are there aspects of the human mind that science and our present understanding have yet to fully explore?

This brings us back to the larger question of the human mind: how much of what we think and feel is shaped by inherited beliefs, how much is influenced by memory and experience, and how much remains beyond our understanding? The answers may differ according to religion, philosophy and science, but the questions themselves lead us towards a subject that is even more difficult to resolve: whether our dreams are simply the mind working through the material of our lives, or whether human consciousness contains aspects that we have not yet learned to explain.

 

 

Another perspective that enters this debate is Scientology, whose teachings describe the human being as a spiritual entity known as the thetan, rather than merely a physical body. According to the Church of Scientology, the mind serves as a means through which this spiritual being interacts with the world. This is a religious and philosophical position, not an established scientific conclusion about consciousness, but it raises questions that have occupied humanity for centuries.

Are we simply our bodies, thoughts and memories, or is there a dimension of human existence that cannot be fully explained through physical processes alone? Neuroscience approaches these questions by studying brain activity, cognition, memory and sleep, while religious traditions draw on spiritual teachings, sacred texts, revelation and personal experience. These approaches are not interchangeable, since they make different claims and rely on different forms of authority. Yet the experience of dreaming brings them into an interesting conversation because, while the body rests, the mind appears capable of creating entire worlds populated by people, places and events that can feel as real as waking life. This leaves us with a question that is easier to ask than to answer: when we dream, what exactly is experiencing that dream – the brain, the mind, consciousness, the spiritual self, or something that our present understanding has not yet adequately explained?

Long before modern neuroscience began investigating the sleeping brain, thinkers such as Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung were already attempting to understand what dreams might reveal about the human mind. Freud, in his influential work “The Interpretation of Dreams,” regarded dreams as meaningful psychological formations connected to our waking experiences, including desires, memories and unconscious processes.

Jung approached the subject from a different perspective, paying particular attention to symbols and the unconscious, and suggesting that dreams could bring to awareness meanings that the conscious mind had not yet recognised. Nevertheless, the interpretation of dreams remains difficult, and Jung’s approach reminds us of the danger of assuming that we can immediately understand everything a dream represents. The words attributed to him in discussions of dream interpretation, “I have no idea what this dream means,” capture an important principle of intellectual humility: before assigning a meaning to an experience, we must be willing to acknowledge that we may not understand it.

This is particularly important when dreams are connected to religion, prophecy, trauma or spiritual belief. A dream can be emotionally powerful without having one obvious explanation, and it can hold personal or spiritual significance for the dreamer without necessarily being a literal prediction of the future. Recognising that uncertainty does not diminish the experience; rather, it allows us to examine it without claiming knowledge we do not possess.

Consider the experience of someone who dreams about an old friend with whom they have not spoken for years. In the dream, the friend appears in a particular room, looking frightened, and tells the dreamer that a phone call will arrive carrying important information about the future.

The dreamer wakes up with a strong impression of what has happened and decides to tell a family member or record the details. A month later, the telephone rings, and the person calling is the very friend who appeared in the dream.

During their conversation, the friend shares information that seems remarkably similar to what the dream appeared to announce. How should such an experience be understood? Was it coincidence, or had the dreamer’s brain unconsciously recognised patterns and clues that had not reached conscious awareness? Could the memory of the dream have changed after the telephone call, making the earlier experience seem more precise than it originally was? Or does the experience raise questions for which we do not yet have a satisfactory explanation? These are reasonable questions, particularly when the dream appears unusually vivid and the later event seems to correspond closely with it. However, the fact that an experience feels extraordinary does not, by itself, establish that a supernatural event has occurred.

Science has not established that ordinary dreams can reliably predict future events through supernatural means, although the brain can process information outside conscious awareness, recognise patterns and form expectations based on subtle clues. It is therefore possible for a dream to appear predictive because the mind has assembled information that the conscious person has not deliberately considered. At the same time, it would be unwise to assume that this explanation automatically accounts for every account of an apparently predictive dream without examining the circumstances.

If the dream was written down before the event occurred, shared with another person at the time, and described specific details that later appeared to match what happened, there would be a clearer basis for investigating the experience than if the account were recalled only after the event. Such evidence would not, on its own, prove prophecy, but it would help distinguish what was recorded beforehand from what might have been reconstructed through later recollection. The important point is that neither blind acceptance nor immediate dismissal offers a satisfactory way of investigating an unusual experience. We should examine the available evidence, consider alternative explanations and remain open to the possibility that our understanding may be incomplete, without treating every explanation as equally supported.

Human memory is not a perfect recording of events. We forget details, reconstruct past experiences and sometimes interpret earlier memories in the light of what happens later. This is particularly relevant when people report dreams that appear to have anticipated a future event. Someone may sincerely remember having dreamed about a particular occurrence, yet the details of that dream may become more precise in their recollection after the occurrence takes place.

This does not necessarily mean the person is deliberately inventing a story; it reflects the fact that memory is a reconstructive process rather than an exact recording. If we want to investigate such experiences seriously, it makes sense to write down dreams as soon as possible, include the date and specific details, preserve the original account without editing it afterwards and compare it with any later event that appears relevant.

It is equally important to consider the details that did not match, how many other dreams were not followed by similar events, and whether the dream was interpreted as predictive before or only after the event occurred. These questions do not eliminate the mystery surrounding dreams. They help prevent our memories and expectations from influencing the conclusions we draw.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.

Breaking news & top stories

Follow The Sun Newspaper

Get live updates & exclusive stories delivered straight to your phone.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.