Pen not a pass to peddle falsehood

By Odi Ehisuan

When  a journalist goes to prison, the headlines write themselves. “Press under siege.” “Democracy in danger.” “Presidential aide jails reporter.” It is a thrilling story, and it has only one flaw: much of it is not true.

Let me say first where I stand, so no one mistakes my meaning. I believe in the freedom of the press, and I believe journalists must be protected to do their work without fear. But that freedom is a shield for the truth. It was never meant to be a stick for beating people with falsehood. That is the whole point of this piece.

Start with the fact that the noisiest commentators skip. Princess Adejoke Orelope-Adefulire, the Senior Special Assistant to the President on Sustainable Development Goals, did not arrest Daniel Ojukwu, and she did not send him to prison. The Nigerian judicial system did.

Justice Joyce Abdulmalik of the Federal High Court in Abuja, hearing a 12-count charge bordering on cyberstalking and criminal defamation, ordered his remand pending the hearing of his bail application. The court noted that the application was filed late, even though the charges had been served on him long before. That is a judge applying procedure. If we want an independent judiciary, we cannot applaud it when it rules our way and call it tyranny when it does not.

Consider, too, how the Princess went about seeking redress. She is a citizen of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, and like every citizen she is entitled to protect her fundamental rights, including her good name. Faced with allegations she says are false and malicious, she did not resort to self-help, and she did not send anyone to intimidate anybody. She submitted a petition to the Nigeria Police Force and let the law do its work. A person with something to hide runs from judicial scrutiny. She walked straight into it. Those who now accuse her of oppression should tell us what they would have preferred: a public servant who ignores the law, or one who obeys it?

Now to the reports that started it all. In 2023, Ojukwu wrote, and the Foundation for Investigative Journalism (FIJ) published, a series of stories. The centrepiece claimed that the Office of the Senior Special Assistant to the President on SDGs paid ₦147.1 million to a “restaurant” to build classrooms in Lagos.

It is a delicious headline. A restaurant building classrooms! The trouble, according to the Office, is that it falls apart on contact with the documents.

The Office produced the paperwork. Records from the Corporate Affairs Commission show that the contractor is a duly registered corporate entity, with valid incorporation and tax clearance documents. It is no roadside canteen. The project was handled by certified professionals with real expertise in construction and engineering.

The classrooms and the Skills Acquisition Centre in Lagos, the Office says, were built to specification, completed, commissioned and put to use, with photographs and exact GPS coordinates to prove it. Even the shifting of the project from its first site in Ajeromi had an ordinary explanation: space constraints, followed by the provision of a new site by the lawmaker who facilitated the project. Nothing here was whispered or hidden. Every point could have been checked by anyone willing to check.

That is where journalism’s own rules come in. The craft rests on fairness, balance, accuracy and objectivity, and at the centre of it sits the right of reply. Before you tell the nation that public money was wasted, you give the accused a real chance to answer. According to the Office, Ojukwu made no genuine effort to seek clarification on the procurement records or the status of the project before going to press. Worse, when the Office offered to take the reporter and his publication to the project sites to see the work for themselves, the offer was declined. The allegations were published anyway.

Pause on that. An investigator is invited to come and look, and he says no. A reporter who wants the truth accepts such an invitation before the sun sets. One who refuses it has told you something about what he was after. Publishing a one-sided, unverified story in the face of an open offer to verify it falls far below the minimum standard of the profession. It looks less like a public-spirited investigation and more like a plan to smear a public servant.

None of this weakens the case for a free press. Section 22 of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, rightly charges the media with holding government responsible and accountable to the people. A country without fearless journalists is a country governed in the dark, and I would defend that principle in any room. But rights come with responsibilities, and the freedom to scrutinise power carries a duty of care. Constitutional privilege is not an absolute licence for recklessness. If it were, it would be a licence for character assassination, and the victim would have no remedy at all.

Think about what that would mean. If every complaint against a journalist is an “attack on the press,” then journalists become the only citizens in Nigeria who cannot be answerable to anyone. The trader wrongly accused of fraud, the teacher falsely painted as a thief, the public servant who has done the work and kept the receipts: all of them would be told to accept the damage in silence. That is not freedom. It is privilege wearing freedom’s clothes.

Journalism is a noble profession, but it is not an immunity cloak. Journalists are citizens, bound by the same laws as every other Nigerian. When any practitioner crosses the line from legitimate inquiry into criminal defamation and cyberstalking, the legal system must be allowed to ensure justice is served, without emotional blackmail and without interference.

Ojukwu, FIJ and their supporters have every right to defend themselves, and the courtroom is the place to do it. If the reporting was accurate, the evidence will say so, and no one will be happier than those of us who care about the press. What they should not do is swap outrage for argument, or ask Nigerians to treat a judicial process as an assault on democracy before a single witness has been heard.

We can defend the press and defend the truth at the same time. In fact, we must. A free press is at its strongest when it is accurate, and a public servant who has done her work is entitled to say so, in court if need be.

• Mr. Ehisuan is a public analyst and sent this piece from Abuja

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.

Breaking news & top stories

Follow The Sun Newspaper

Get live updates & exclusive stories delivered straight to your phone.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.