Don’t compromise your independence, be firm, CJN tells new A’Court Justices

CJN

Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun

From Godwin Tsa, Abuja

Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, yesterday charged 12 newly sworn-in Justices of the Court of Appeal to resist political pressure, personal influence and intimidation, warning that loyalty to senior colleagues must never override their independence or commitment to justice.

Speaking at their swearing-in ceremony at the Supreme Court complex, Abuja, the CJN urged the new appellate Justices to demonstrate courage in their decisions, even when their interpretation of the law differed from that of other members of a judicial panel.

She warned that the desire for unanimity, professional relationships or fear of public criticism must not compromise their responsibility to decide cases according to the law and their conscience.

Kekere-Ekun said collegiality at the appellate court should promote sound judicial reasoning rather than suppress independent opinions, stressing that every Justice remained personally accountable for his or her decisions.

She urged them to decide cases “without being unduly influenced by seniority, reputation, personal affinity or the desire for unanimity.”

According to her, where a Justice disagrees with the majority after carefully examining a case, such disagreement should be expressed with courage, clarity and respect.

She described a well-reasoned dissenting judgment as an important feature of appellate adjudication that could contribute to the development of the law, warning, however, that differences in judicial opinions must never degenerate into personal disagreements.

The strength of a collegiate court, she said, lies in the quality of its reasoning and integrity of its deliberations, rather than “an artificial appearance of unanimity.”

Among the 12 new Justices, whose elevation was recommended by the National Judicial Council (NJC) at its May 13 meeting, are former Federal High Court judges James Omotosho and Emeka Nwite.

Others are Yakubu Abdulhammeed Mohammed, Abodunde Monisola Oluwatoyin, Ajuwa Raphael, Abua Elias Ojie, Ijohor Mbalamen Jennifer, Shuaibu Sabiu Bala, Buba Dauda Njane, Kado Sanusi, Ademola Enikuomehin and Dadom Julcit Veronica.

They were drawn from the High Courts of Gombe, Bayelsa, Cross River, Benue, Kebbi, Taraba and Ondo states, the Federal High Court, National Industrial Court and Customary Courts of Appeal of Ekiti and Plateau states.

The CJN reminded the new Justices that their elevation marked a significant transition from sitting as sole judges to participating in panels where decisions are reached collectively.

She said the new responsibility demanded intellectual openness, mutual respect, thorough preparation and willingness to reconsider initial positions after deliberations with colleagues.

While encouraging them to seek guidance from experienced Justices, Kekere-Ekun maintained that such consultations must not undermine their independence of thought.

She also cautioned against allowing public opinion to dictate judicial decisions, noting that judgments now attract immediate scrutiny and commentary.

According to her, public approval must never justify a departure from the law, just as criticism should not discourage a Justice from delivering a decision supported by the law and conscience.

The CJN specifically warned against political, financial, social and personal pressures, including influences arising from professional familiarity and established relationships.

She urged the Justices to conduct themselves in ways that would leave no reasonable doubt about their impartiality.

Kekere-Ekun noted that the Court of Appeal handles civil, criminal, constitutional, electoral, commercial and labour disputes, among others, and serves as the final court in certain matters under the Constitution.

She said its responsibility extended beyond affirming or overturning lower court decisions to correcting errors, clarifying legal principles and promoting consistency in judicial interpretation.

The CJN also reminded the Justices that an appeal was not an opportunity to rehear a case merely because another judicial officer might have reached a different conclusion.

She urged them to examine trial records carefully and intervene only where justified by law, particularly when reviewing findings of fact made by judges who had the opportunity to observe witnesses.

On the growing use of artificial intelligence in judicial work, Kekere-Ekun said technology could assist legal research and case management but warned against relying on unverified authorities or surrendering judicial reasoning to automated systems.

She insisted that judgments must remain “the product of your own considered judgment.”

The CJN concluded that the dignity and credibility of the judiciary depended not merely on judgments delivered in court but also on the integrity, conduct and professional relationships of those entrusted with judicial authority.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.

Breaking news & top stories

Follow The Sun Newspaper

Get live updates & exclusive stories delivered straight to your phone.

Breaking news & top stories

Stay connected with The Sun Newspaper

Get breaking news, exclusive stories, and live updates delivered straight to your phone. Join thousands of readers already following us on Whatsapp Channel and Telegram.